Welcome to First Slice Pie Cafe Manor
At First Slice Pie Cafe Manor, nestled in Chicago's charming neighborhood, a sweet and savory journey awaits. This quaint establishment is renowned for its exceptional pies, like the crowd-favorite French Silk and the zesty Key Lime. Customers rave about the delightful sandwiches, hearty soups, and kid-friendly options that cater to every palate. With a welcoming atmosphere and attentive service, the cafe combines community spirit with culinary artistry. From the tantalizing chocolate pecan pie to the vibrant Latin Hip Hop salad, each dish tells a story of passion and quality. First Slice is more than a cafe; it's a beloved gathering place for food lovers.
First Slice Pie Cafe Manor: Reviews & Ratings
So I've never been to the physical location but my friends had their pies at a party and ever since I can't stop ordering from First Slice. I'm obsessed with their sandwiches! They have the BEST combo. Sandwich salad chips & I always add a slice of pie too. My favorite pie is key lime I think but I've tried a hand full of theirs and they are all delicious. They have a really unique yummy balsamic pear pie. Their apple and cherry pies are phenomenal too. Looking forward to trying more things on the menu. Oh and my daughter loves their Mac and cheese. Thanks for feeding us! 3
I like the unpretentiousness of First Slice though some would be warranted based on the quality of the food and service. On my first visit, I ordered the Cuban sandwich, mocha, and a French silk small pie (to take home; it was eaten within days). I enjoyed it all. There's not a ton of seating space, but we all made do and shared it well knowing we had found a unique restaurant. The only knock is the front door didn't close all the way on a cold day.
Food has always been incredible. The Latin Hip Hop salad is a neighborhood favorite of mine, and every pie has been outstanding, with a special nod to the chocolate pecan, French silk, and chocolate peanut butter. As for the service - the staff went above and beyond for my Thanksgiving pie this year. A mix-up caused my pie to be ready at the Andersonville location, not Manor, the day before the holiday. After a night and morning spent at the emergency vet and with bronchitis myself, that extra distance felt insurmountable. The woman I spoke with on the phone (Jennifer? I regret that the stress of the day affected my memory) tracked down my order, then promised to bring it from Andersonville to the Manor for me, since she had to make a trip over there that afternoon. It had been such an awful day, and that little bit of kindness was much appreciated. (Plus the pie was phenomenal - warming up the chocolate pecan makes it even more dreamy.)
This little pie shop is so darn cute! The pies are delicious, and they also have other great cafe options like soups, sandwiches and beverages. The staff is friendly and the atmosphere is absolutely charming.
Love this place! The sandwiches are great, there's a good variety, and the price is pretty good too (usually 10 to 13 bucks). The location itself is a little bare but it's still nice to sit and listen to the train roll by. Staff is also very nice.
Stopped by on a whim and ordered a slice of the mango margarita cheesecake pie (pictured) and the broccoli cheddar quiche. Both were amazing! Great, helpful service and chill vibe as well.
The French silk pie is the bomb. Also the Cuban sandwich is so zesty and tasty!!! Loved them both. Sorry, I ate the Cuban before getting a good picture!
Delicious! Moved away from Chicago a little over 5 years ago and was back visiting for the weekend. So happy to see this delicious spot still open. This voracious carnivore had a vegetarian sandwich and a slice of pie as an appetizer (life is uncertain, eat dessert first) and it was all amazing.
Location
-
4664 N Manor Ave, Chicago, IL 60625, United States Hotline: +1 773-267-0169
Welcome to First Slice Pie Cafe Manor, a charming little gem nestled in the heart of Chicago at 4664 N Manor Ave. Whether you’re a pie aficionado or a casual eater, this delightful cafe has something to tempt every palate. With a reputation for delectable pies and a cozy atmosphere, First Slice has become a beloved spot for locals and visitors alike.
The menu here is a carefully curated selection of savory quiches, mouthwatering sandwiches, and, of course, an array of heavenly pies. The Blueberry Cheesecake stands out with its velvety texture and delightful flavor profile, combining fresh blueberries, cream cheese, and a buttery graham cracker crust for just $9.50. Vegetarians will appreciate the selection of quiches, such as the Broccoli and Cheddar Quiche and the Mediterranean Quiche, both priced at $10.00 and perfectly accompanied by a side salad.
- Broccoli and Cheddar Quiche: A delightful mix of fresh broccoli and rich cheddar cheese.
- Greek Quiche: Spinach, goat cheese, sundried tomatoes, and mushrooms come together in a vegetarian delight.
For families, First Slice offers kid-friendly options like the Kids Macaroni and Cheese and grilled cheese, ensuring that even the little ones leave satisfied. The adults can indulge in beautifully crafted sandwiches that complement any dish perfectly.
Customers rave about their selections, from the Cuban Sandwich to the Latin Hip Hop Salad, exemplifying the cafe's commitment to quality and flavor. One particularly commendable dish is their Key Lime Pie, which has captured the hearts of many, alongside the unique Balsamic Pear Pie—a true testament to their adventurous spirit in pie-making.
Two aspects truly set First Slice apart: the quality of their offerings and the warmth of their service. Many reviews highlight the unpretentious ambiance and the kindness of the staff. A notable story describes how a staff member went above and beyond to ensure that a Thanksgiving pie made it to a customer who was in need, showcasing the community spirit that this cafe embraces.
The atmosphere at First Slice Pie Cafe Manor is as inviting as its menu. It's a cozy spot where patrons can unwind and enjoy their chosen delights amidst friendly chatter and the gentle sound of trains passing by. It may not have extensive seating, but the engaging vibe makes sharing tables a delightful part of the experience.
In conclusion, whether you are popping in for a quick bite, indulging in a leisurely meal, or picking up a slice of pie to go, First Slice Pie Cafe Manor promises an experience filled with flavor, comfort, and a warm community feel. Don't miss the chance to explore their offerings and become part of the growing number of fans who can't stop raving about this wonderful cafe!